Follow

@feonixrift @freakazoid @dredmorbius @mathew @o

Democracy-as-we-know-it(-Jim), anyway.

Current implementations are tilted heavily (if not always obviously) towards protecting existing power-structures.

It's pretty easy to imagine small improvements that would significantly undercut this tendency, and not hard to design improvements that would do more than that.

· · Web · 1 · 0 · 1

@woozle @o @mathew @dredmorbius @feonixrift I think the big problem with democracy is that we treat it as if it has some magical power. Instead of fighting for human rights and rule of law, we fight for "democracy", even though the only rights democracy can protect by itself are the rights of the majority of the enfranchised, i.e. the people who least need it, and people will almost always vote *against* rule of law as long as it gets them what they want.

@feonixrift @dredmorbius @mathew @o @woozle I see democracy as a tool for implementing rule of law, because it allows succession of governments in a way that's always governed by law, whereas hereditary succession has always ended up with edge cases and conflicts. And of course can produce rulers who are so incompetent or evil that it causes revolutions where none were necessary (cf. the French and American revolutions).

@woozle @o @mathew @dredmorbius @feonixrift Democracy certainly produces incompetent leaders, but as long as there's rule of law and terms of short enough length, people will just wait rather than revolting. And of course lack of revolt is a necessary condition for rule of law.

@woozle @o @mathew @dredmorbius @feonixrift Randomly selecting representatives from among the population may well produce as good of or better results than having the population at large vote. You couldn't pick someone with as much power as the US President has that way, but those randomly selected representatives could certainly choose someone. And they'd probably do a better job since they'd be more visible and have some feeling of responsibility for their choice.

@freakazoid @feonixrift @dredmorbius @mathew @o @woozle

Democracy is obsolete, yo.

(not that we don't use plenty of obsolete things, but we'd be better of not to).

@freakazoid @feonixrift @dredmorbius @o @woozle
"Randomly selecting representatives from among the population […] You couldn't pick someone with as much power as the US President has that way"

I'd take a randomly selected member of the population over the current US President.

Sign in to participate in the conversation
Toot.Cat

The social network of the future: No ads, no corporate surveillance, ethical design, and decentralization! Own your data with Mastodon!